These issues were at the center of the regional panel discussion “Strengthening state aid governance in the Western Balkans: transparency, effectiveness and EU alignment”, organized by Finance Think, which brought together more than 40 representatives of institutions from Western Balkan countries. The conclusion was clear: there is a pressing need to establish a central state aid register that would enable greater transparency, better coordination, and more systematic measurement of the effects of different programs.

The Minister of Finance, Gordana Dimitrieska-Kochoska, emphasized that this is a substantial fiscal amount that must be treated as an investment rather than a burden:

“State aid must not represent a burden on public finances, but rather an investment in competitiveness and sustainable growth. According to data from the Commission for Protection of Competition, state aid amounted to €206 million in 2023, or around 1.5 percent of GDP, while in 2024 it reached €235.2 million, or 1.52 percent of GDP, which underscores the need for a high level of accountability and transparency.”

The Executive Director of Finance Think, Blagica Petreski, pointed out that there is currently a lack of micro-level data on which companies receive state aid, from which sectors, and for what purposes, limiting the quality of policy design.

“Our recommendation is to establish the central state aid register as soon as possible, as there is a wide range of programs being offered. This would not only increase transparency, but also allow for more detailed measurement of effects. When planning the introduction of a specific measure or program, an impact evaluation of potential effects is essential, and once implemented, the measure should be evaluated to avoid repeating past mistakes where large amounts of funds were spent without tangible results. State aid is one of the most underestimated topics, given that budgetary allocations under this heading reach up to 2 percent of GDP in some years, particularly during crisis periods.”

The post Over €200 million annually for state aid – a need for greater transparency and control first appeared on Finance Think.

The post Over €200 million annually for state aid – a need for greater transparency and control appeared first on Finance Think.

The key question is not whether the minimum wage should increase, but at what pace and on which economic foundations. An excessive increase in the minimum wage and all other wages in the economy without a parallel increase in newly created value entails several risks.

The first risk is pressure on prices. Inflation in January declined to 3.2% year-on-year, down from 4.1% in December, but it remains above the level considered stable and above the euro area level of 1.7%, which is an important reference given the fixed exchange rate of the denar against the euro.

Persistent inflation in North Macedonia is the result of several factors, ranked by their importance:

             1. Increased income in the economy, resulting from strong real wage growth over the past several years, largely due to chronic labor shortages in the labor market; as well as from the significant increase in pension income, which over a relatively short period exceeded 30% of the average pension (Graph 1).

Graph 1 – Dynamics of Median Income in the Economy

Source: Own calculations based on the Survey on Income and Living Conditions of the State Statistical Office.

Especially in the second half of 2025 and at present, persistent inflation is largely the result of demand-side pressure. Wages – the main component of income in the economy – grew faster than productivity over almost the entire period, such that in 2024 compared to 2017, the average wage was higher by 79.9%, the minimum wage by as much as 88%, while productivity increased by only 49.8% (all indicators are nominal growth, Graph 2). This divergence between income and productivity is macroeconomically unsustainable and directly translates into price pressure.

Graph 2 – Labor Productivity and Wage Growth, Annual Growth

Source: State Statistical Office.

          2. The behavior of certain actors along the supply chain, particularly in food sub-markets, prevented the easing of price pressure from global food markets from being transmitted quickly and proportionately to the domestic economy. Nevertheless, it is worth noting that company profits grew more slowly than household incomes, which does not provide strong support for the claim that a shift in income distribution in favor of employers is the source of inflationary pressure (Graph 3). In other words, inflation at present cannot be explained simply and exclusively as “corporate greed,” but rather as a combination of strong demand and structural market constraints.

An exception is the crisis year 2022, when profit growth outpaced household income growth, indicating that firms passed global price pressures onto final consumers – possibly more than proportionately – contributing to profit accumulation. This supports the so-called “solidarity tax,” which was later repealed by the Constitutional Court; as well as full support for the implementation of the Unfair Trading Practices Law and monitoring potential anti-competitive behavior by the Commission for Protection of Competition.

Graph 3 – Corporate Profits and Workers’ Income, Annual Growth

Source: State Statistical Office.

             3. Inflation expectations have also been raised, in part, by repeated short-term measures of freezing prices and margins on food products.

Accordingly, a potential excessive increase in the total wage bill in the economy over the short to medium term would result only in persistent prices, i.e., inflationary pressure that would be difficult to contain without particularly restrictive monetary and fiscal measures. For social dialogue, it is especially important that the minimum wage be aligned with the creation of new value added in the economy, that is, with productivity.

According to currently available data, North Macedonia has a minimum wage (measured by purchasing power standard) similar to or the same as Malta, Slovakia, Montenegro, and Bulgaria, while having higher productivity (again measured by purchasing power standard) only than Montenegro among these countries. By contrast, Czechia, Latvia, and Estonia have lower minimum wages but higher productivity (Graph 4).

Graph 4 – Minimum Wage and Productivity in Europe, by Purchasing Power Parity (2025)

Source: ILOSTAT and Eurostat. Luxembourg and Ireland are not shown due to very high productivity. Countries not shown are those without a statutory minimum wage.

The second risk is disruption of fiscal consolidation. After the pandemic, North Macedonia has pursued a limited pace of fiscal consolidation, implying a gradual reduction of the budget deficit and public debt. However, the budget deficit is still projected above 3% of GDP, and total public debt is approaching and during 2026 will exceed the psychological threshold and fiscal rule of 60% of GDP. In this context, the expert community calls for fiscal consolidation to be viewed not only through the prism of the budget deficit, but also through the need to significantly eliminate unproductive expenditures on the spending side of the budget.

A major expenditure item is state aid, i.e., subsidies. In the period 2019–2022, North Macedonia introduced subsidized social contributions for wage increases ranging from 600 to 6,000 denars per worker per month. This subsidy was the second-largest form of state aid after agricultural subsidies (or third, if COVID-19 state aid in 2020 is included; see Graph 5). Undertaking obligations for state wage subsidization not only prevents easing inflationary pressure but also represents a direct attack on fiscal consolidation and a transfer of costs from the private sector to all taxpayers, and should therefore be fully excluded as a policy option.

Graph 5 – State Aid by Type in 2020

The third risk is disruption of the labor market. In conditions of a tight but lethargic labor market (with an activity rate that is not increasing), an excessive increase in the minimum wage will not lead to higher unemployment. Such an outcome is unlikely, given labor market dynamics and past empirical evidence confirming that the link between the minimum wage and layoffs in North Macedonia is very weak. However, this is due to the fact that employers may resort to other adjustment mechanisms, primarily de-formalization or semi-formalization of jobs.

This would imply the absence of a written employment contract (fully informal worker) or insuring a worker for fewer hours than actually worked and paying the remainder through so-called envelope wages (partially informal worker). This adjustment channel under conditions of an excessive minimum wage increase is very likely, given the rising trend in the share of informal workers in recent quarters (Graph 6). This type of adjustment is particularly harmful because it undermines both worker protection and the state’s revenue base.

Graph 6 – Share of Informal Workers in Total Employment

Source: State Statistical Office.

In conclusion, the increase in the minimum wage is socially justified, but it must be aligned with productivity growth and the real capacity of the economy. Otherwise, excessive wage increases generate persistent inflationary pressure, constrain the space for fiscal consolidation, and increase the risk of de-formalization of labor relations. Therefore, the key challenge is not whether the minimum wage should increase, but at what pace and on which economic foundations, in order to preserve both workers’ purchasing power and macroeconomic stability.

Finance Think recommends that the Government actively engages in social dialogue as a third key party and mediator between workers and employers, providing reasoned, evidence-based support. Recognition of the factual situation by all participants in social dialogue is a fundamental prerequisite for preserving both workers’ living standards and macroeconomic stability.

The post FT Opinion 67 on the Minimum Wage, Productivity, Inflation, and Informal Employment first appeared on Finance Think.

The post FT Opinion 67 on the Minimum Wage, Productivity, Inflation, and Informal Employment appeared first on Finance Think.

The debate underscored that although state aid has proven to be an important anti-cyclical tool—particularly during periods of crisis—its role cannot be assessed solely through the volume of resources allocated. Participants emphasized that the key challenge lies in ensuring that state aid is well-targeted, effective, and aligned with long-term development objectives and EU rules. Recent regional trends point to increasingly diverging approaches across countries, raising questions about coherence, effectiveness, and the risk of ad-hoc policy interventions.

A central takeaway from the panel was the critical importance of transparency and accountability. Fragmented and non-standardized data continue to limit meaningful monitoring and evaluation of state aid in the region. In this context, the discussion highlighted the value of the newly developed regional platform on state aid as a practical tool to support evidence-based policymaking, cross-country comparison, and informed public debate—ultimately contributing to stronger governance and closer EU alignment in the Western Balkans.

The post Strengthening state aid governance in the Western Balkans first appeared on Finance Think.

The post Strengthening state aid governance in the Western Balkans appeared first on Finance Think.

What does this mean for the economy? Can economic growth or stagnation be expected this year, how will inflation evolve, and what can the business sector anticipate?

In the new episode of FinSight, we speak with Blagica Petreski, Executive Director of Finance Think – Institute for Economic Research and Policy. We analyze where budget funds are being allocated, the burden of public debt, how realistic the projected growth of 3.5 percent is, and whether rising wages could further fuel inflation.

The discussion also focuses on labor productivity, the grey economy, the effects of the “My VAT” project, and the key reforms the economy needs to achieve sustainable growth and a higher standard of living.

The post Blagica Petreski on FinSight: Public Debt and the Economic Outlook in 2026 first appeared on Finance Think.

The post Blagica Petreski on FinSight: Public Debt and the Economic Outlook in 2026 appeared first on Finance Think.

The post #Fiscal accountability is at the core of our story in Civica Mobilitas first appeared on Finance Think.

The post #Fiscal accountability is at the core of our story in Civica Mobilitas appeared first on Finance Think.

The post NEW Policy Study 57! first appeared on Finance Think.

The post NEW Policy Study 57! appeared first on Finance Think.

The post Debate on a flagship topic related to our monitoring of the Reform Agenda first appeared on Finance Think.

The post Debate on a flagship topic related to our monitoring of the Reform Agenda appeared first on Finance Think.

Today, December 12, 2025, we held a Training on Monitoring Public Procurement, where 20 representatives from local public institutions, civil society organizations, and the media from Prilep and Krushevo gained new information and knowledge on the proper monitoring and implementation of public spending.It is time for efficient and transparent public procurement!

The post Training on Monitoring Public Procurement at the Municipal Level first appeared on Finance Think.

The post Training on Monitoring Public Procurement at the Municipal Level appeared first on Finance Think.

The first Webinar on the alignment of state aid regulation with EU Acquis was held, attended by 35+ representatives of public institutions that control, manage and/or grant state aid in the Western Balkan countries.

Olgica Spevec, an expert on state aid and competition policies, shared Croatia’s experience through practical challenges and lessons learned in the accession phases – from the perspective of a negotiator for Chapter 8 and President of the Croatian Competition Council.

The post Webinar on the alignment of state aid regulation first appeared on Finance Think.

The post Webinar on the alignment of state aid regulation appeared first on Finance Think.

We kindly ask you to take 5 minutes of your valuable time and tell us about your satisfaction with public services by completing the questionnaire above

#CHinMK #CivicaMobilitas
Civica Mobilitas
Macedonian Medical Association
Youth Educational Forum – YEF
@youtheducationalforum
@mcgo_mcec_mk
MCEC – Macedonian Center for Civic Education
@360stepeni
360 Degrees

The post 📣 We want to hear your opinion! first appeared on Finance Think.

The post 📣 We want to hear your opinion! appeared first on Finance Think.